An independent contractor in Ontario is a self-employed individual or business that provides services to another company or client while operating a business on their own account.
Unlike an employee, an independent contractor generally has greater control over how their work is performed and may assume financial risks associated with running their business.
However, being called an independent contractor does not necessarily determine a worker’s legal status. Courts examine the actual working relationship, including control, financial risk, ownership of equipment and other relevant factors.
The Supreme Court of Canada addressed these considerations in 2001 SCC 59, explaining that the central question is whether the worker is performing services as someone in business on their own account.
What Are the Characteristics of an Independent Contractor?
Independent contractors generally operate their own businesses and have greater independence in how they provide services to clients.
According to the factors discussed by the Supreme Court of Canada in 2001 SCC 59, characteristics that may indicate an independent contractor relationship include:
- Control over work: The worker has greater freedom to determine when, where and how services are performed.
- Ownership of equipment: The worker provides their own tools, equipment or resources.
- Hiring assistance: The worker may hire employees or subcontractors to complete the work.
- Financial risk: The worker assumes business expenses and may experience financial losses.
- Opportunity for profit: The worker may increase earnings through business decisions, efficiency or negotiating fees.
- Multiple clients: The worker may provide services to more than one company rather than working exclusively for a single organization.
These characteristics are not a checklist that must be satisfied in every case. Courts consider the relationship as a whole, and no single factor automatically determines whether someone is an independent contractor.
How Is an Independent Contractor Different From an Employee?
The main distinction is whether the worker is operating an independent business or working as part of an employer’s business.
Employees generally work under an employer’s direction and are protected by applicable employment standards legislation. Genuine independent contractors operate their own businesses and are generally not covered by Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA).
Ontario’s Guide to the Employment Standards Act: Employee Status explains that determining whether a worker is an employee or independent contractor requires consideration of the actual working relationship.
For a detailed explanation of the legal tests and differences in employment rights, read our article on independent contractors vs. employees in Ontario.
Can an Independent Contractor Actually Be an Employee?
Yes. A worker may be legally classified as an employee even if their agreement describes them as an independent contractor.
For example, a worker might be required to follow a company-established schedule, report to a supervisor, use company equipment and perform substantially the same duties as employees.
These circumstances may suggest an employment relationship, although none automatically establishes employee status.
In 2009 ONCA 916, the Ontario Court of Appeal considered the distinction between employees, independent contractors and dependent contractors. The decision illustrates why courts must examine the substance of a working relationship rather than relying solely on contractual labels.
Section 5.1 of Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 prohibits employers from treating a person who is an employee as though they are not an employee for the purposes of the Act.
This practice is commonly known as employee misclassification. Learn more about employee misclassification in Ontario.
What Rights Do Independent Contractors Have in Ontario?
Independent contractors have legal rights, but those rights differ from the protections available to employees.
Genuine independent contractors generally rely on the terms of their service agreements and applicable contract law to establish their rights and obligations.
Depending on the circumstances, these rights may include:
- Payment for services: The right to receive compensation according to the terms of an enforceable agreement.
- Contractual protections: The ability to enforce applicable terms concerning payment, responsibilities and termination.
- Business independence: The ability to negotiate fees, establish business arrangements and provide services to other clients, subject to contractual obligations.
- Legal remedies: The ability to pursue remedies for a breach of contract, including unpaid fees or other losses where legally recoverable.
Unlike employees covered by the ESA, genuine independent contractors generally do not qualify for statutory employment benefits such as minimum wage, vacation pay, overtime pay, public holiday pay or statutory termination pay.
However, workers who have been incorrectly classified as independent contractors may have rights under employment standards legislation.
Can Independent Contractors Receive Vacation Pay or Overtime Pay?
Genuine independent contractors are generally not entitled to vacation pay or overtime pay under Ontario’s ESA.
Employees covered by the ESA may qualify for these entitlements, subject to applicable exemptions and eligibility requirements.
If a worker has been incorrectly classified as an independent contractor, they may be entitled to unpaid employment benefits, depending on their circumstances and applicable limitation periods.
For further information, see our guides to vacation pay in Ontario and overtime pay in Ontario.
What Happens When an Independent Contractor Agreement Ends?
When an independent contractor relationship ends, the worker’s rights generally depend on the terms of the agreement and applicable contract law.
A genuine independent contractor may have contractual rights relating to termination, unpaid fees or other obligations. Whether notice of termination is required depends on the agreement and the circumstances.
Ontario common law also recognizes a category of workers known as dependent contractors.
Dependent contractors are not employees, but their economic dependence on a company may give rise to common law reasonable notice rights when the working relationship ends.
In 2009 ONCA 916, the Ontario Court of Appeal recognized the importance of distinguishing independent contractors from dependent contractors when determining potential notice entitlements.
Read more about independent contractor termination and notice rights and dependent contractors in Ontario.
What Should You Do If You Think You Have Been Misclassified?
If you signed an independent contractor agreement but your working relationship resembles employment, consider how the arrangement operates in practice.
Questions worth considering include:
- Does the company control your working hours and responsibilities?
- Are you permitted to work for other clients?
- Who provides the equipment and resources required for your work?
- Do you assume meaningful business expenses or financial risks?
- Can you hire others to assist with the work?
- Are you performing duties similar to those of the company’s employees?
- Have you been denied vacation pay, overtime pay or other employment entitlements?
The answers may help identify potential classification concerns, but no single question determines your legal status.
If you believe you have been misclassified, consider keeping copies of your agreement, payment records, work schedules and communications about your responsibilities. These documents may help an employment lawyer assess your working relationship.
Understanding Your Independent Contractor Rights
Whether someone is an independent contractor or employee depends on the actual nature of the working relationship, not simply the wording of an agreement.
Workers who have been misclassified may have employment rights they were previously denied. Others may qualify as dependent contractors and have certain rights when their working relationship ends.
If you are unsure about your legal classification or believe you have been denied employment entitlements, Monkhouse Law Employment Lawyers can review your circumstances and explain your potential rights. Complete the form below to request a free 30-minute phone consultation.

