Sometimes Even The Right to Reinstatement Can Be of a Benefit to Employees From a Tax Perspective

In Canada, when an employee is terminated without cause – that is, without having engaged in serious misconduct warranting a termination for cause – they are entitled to notice of their termination or pay in lieu thereof. Unless an employee’s contract limits their entitlements on termination, an employee can generally expect to receive between 3-5 weeks of notice for each year of service although in certain circumstances an employee may well be entitled to more than 5 weeks of notice for each year of service. Although most employees will be terminated and provided with pay in lieu of notice, meaning they are not actually required to work during the notice period, they are not entitled to collect employment insurance (“EI”) until after their termination pay has run out. This is because pay in lieu of notice constitutes “earnings” as per the Employment Insurance Act, SC, 1996 c 23 and the Employment Insurance Regulations, SOR/96-332.

By way of example, if on termination, an employee receives a lump-sum payment worth three months’ pay, then the employee is ineligible to receive EI benefits for three months after termination.

Practically, this can be an issue when an employee commences litigation claiming that the employer has failed to provide sufficient termination pay, but in the interim, collects EI benefits. If the employee settles with their former employer for amounts that represent further pay in lieu of notice, this can often trigger an obligation to repay EI benefits already received. Terminated employees are not meant to collect both termination pay and EI benefits in respect of the same period of time.

There is, however, a creative way in which an employee can settle a lawsuit for additional funds and avoid the obligation to repay EI that has already been received.

Where an employee who has been terminated is entitled to seek reinstatement, the employee can relinquish that right in exchange for a sum of money. Sums received from the relinquishment of a right to reinstatement, however, are not deductible earnings under the Employment Insurance Act. The foregoing is confirmed in Meehan v Canada (Attorney General), 2003 FCA 368 and more recently in Canada (Attorney General) v Warren, 2012 FCA 74. The theory is that an employee who waives their right to seek reinstatement is not receiving a longer notice period or money that represents income; they are only accepting a payment that compensates them for giving up the right to ask for their job back. Consequently, sums paid out in exchange for the relinquishment of a right to seek reinstatement do not represent income, but rather something wholly different.

Accordingly, in situations where an employee has already collected EI benefits but is seeking a stronger severance package from the employer, the ability to settle for sums paid out in exchange for waiving one’s right to reinstatement can unlock more value for the employee by allowing the employee to keep any EI already received. To avoid the need to repay EI, however, it is necessary that:

The employee actually has the right to seek reinstatement;
The employee has in fact made a claim for reinstatement; and
The settlement agreement clearly provides that the employee was paid a sum of money to relinquish their right to reinstatement.

Unionized employees and federally regulated employees have the right to seek reinstatement, and can therefore benefit from claiming reinstatement to allow for a more favourable settlement in the event of litigation with an employer. Conversely, provincially regulated employees in Canada are generally not entitled to seek reinstatement.

If you have been terminated and believe you may be able to seek reinstatement as a remedy, you should speak with a lawyer. Although you may not end up reinstated to your job, by making a claim for reinstatement with the help of an experienced employment lawyer, you can maximize your financial well-being on termination. Call Monkhouse Law today for a free 30-minute phone consultation.

Call us for a FREE 30 minute phone consultation at 416-907-9249 or submit a callback request

30-Minute Free Consultation

Are you looking for legal help for an employment issue?

We ask a few key questions below to better understand your situation. Please take a moment to complete our confidential form.

Once submitted, your responses will be reviewed by a licensed legal professional at Monkhouse Law, regulated by the Law Society of Ontario.

If we may be able to assist, we’ll follow up with next steps — this may include additional questions or outlining how we could work together.

We understand this may be a stressful time. Thank you for reaching out and taking the first step.

Please fill out this form to help us understand your employment situation.

Please note: This is a private and confidential form to assess whether we may be able to help you. Completing this form does not create a lawyer–client relationship. Legal services can only begin once a formal agreement is signed. While we review every submission carefully, we are not able to take on all cases.

First & Last Name (required)

Email Address (required)

Where are you located? (required)

Phone Number (required)

Do you belong to a union?
YesNo

Your salary range or salary of the employee in question? (required)

Years working for employer or years in operation? (required)

What issue would you like to discuss? (required)

Author
Recent Posts

Monkhouse Law

Toronto Employment Lawyers at Monkhouse Law

Employment Lawyers at Monkhouse Law specialize in Employment Law, Human Rights Law, and Disability Insurance Law. We serve employees, independent contractors and employers, and strive to get optimal results for every client through skilled advocacy and research on each matter. We have successfully represented clients before all levels of court in Ontario, including the Superior Court, the Divisional Appeals Court, and the Court of Appeal as well as the Supreme Court of Canada.